Human moral traditions across cultures repeatedly return to the same insight: a life pulled toward extremes becomes unstable, while a life guided by balance becomes strong. Aristotle expressed this insight through his Doctrine of the Mean; the Buddha embodied it in the Middle Way; Freemasonry transmits it symbolically through the Four Cardinal Virtues and the Working Tools of the Craft. Though separated by centuries and cultures, all three traditions converge on a single discipline—the refinement of human nature through conscious restraint, wisdom, and practice.
This essay argues that Aristotle’s definition of courage as the mean between rashness and cowardice provides a structural key for understanding the Middle Way of the Buddha and the Masonic pursuit of virtue. Through prudence, temperance, fortitude, and justice, the Mason learns not to deny his nature, but to shape it. The Working Tools become practical instruments for walking this narrow path between excess and deficiency.
Aristotle and the Architecture of Virtue
In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle defines moral virtue as a disposition developed through habit, guided by reason, and oriented toward balance. Virtue, he argues, is destroyed by excess and deficiency and preserved by the mean (Aristotle, trans. 1999). Courage serves as Aristotle’s clearest example. The courageous person fears the right things, at the right time, for the right reasons. One who exceeds in confidence becomes rash; one who exceeds in fear becomes cowardly. Courage stands between these extremes, not as compromise, but as excellence.
Crucially, Aristotle does not describe the mean as a mathematical midpoint. The mean is relative to the person and the circumstance and must be discerned through practical wisdom, or phronesis. This emphasis on discernment prevents virtue from becoming mechanical. It also establishes courage as a governing virtue: without the strength to act rightly under pressure, the other virtues collapse.
The Buddha and the Discipline of the Middle Way
The Buddha arrives at a similar conclusion through lived experience rather than philosophical abstraction. In the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, the Buddha recounts his rejection of both sensual indulgence and extreme asceticism, declaring both unprofitable and obstructive to awakening (Bodhi, 2000). The Middle Way he proclaims avoids these extremes and gives rise to clarity, peace, and liberation from suffering.
Like Aristotle’s mean, the Middle Way is not passivity or comfort. It demands ethical conduct, mental discipline, and wisdom, expressed through the Noble Eightfold Path. Right effort, right mindfulness, and right understanding require sustained attention and restraint. Desire is not annihilated but understood; fear is not indulged but examined. Where Aristotle seeks human flourishing within society, the Buddha seeks liberation from suffering, yet both insist that imbalance leads to disorder and that discipline restores harmony.
Freemasonry as Moral Translation
Freemasonry does not present itself as a philosophical system or a religious path. Instead, it transmits moral instruction through symbols, allegory, and labor. Albert Pike described Masonry as a system of morality veiled in allegory and illustrated by symbols (Pike, 1871). These symbols give form to ancient insights without binding them to a single metaphysical framework.
The Four Cardinal Virtues—prudence, temperance, fortitude, and justice—enter Freemasonry from classical tradition and function as pillars of character. Each virtue represents a specific form of balance, and together they form a moral architecture remarkably consistent with both Aristotle’s ethics and the Buddha’s Middle Way.
Prudence: Discerning the Mean
Prudence governs judgment. Aristotle identifies it as the intellectual virtue that enables correct deliberation about what is good and expedient (Aristotle, trans. 1999). Without prudence, the mean cannot be identified, and action becomes reckless or timid.
The Buddha similarly emphasizes right understanding as the foundation of the path. Ethical conduct without wisdom risks becoming rigid; discipline without understanding becomes self-harm. In Masonic symbolism, prudence is reflected in the Square and the Trestleboard. The Square tests actions against moral rectitude, while the Trestleboard reminds the Mason that wise planning must precede action. Prudence teaches when to act, when to refrain, and how to remain aligned with purpose.
Temperance: Restraining Excess
Temperance concerns the governance of desire. Aristotle rejects both indulgence and insensibility, arguing that virtue requires educated appetite. The Buddha identifies craving as the root of suffering, not because desire exists, but because unchecked attachment enslaves the mind.
Freemasonry expresses temperance through the Compasses, which circumscribe passions and keep them within due bounds. The Gavel, which removes superfluities from the rough stone, reinforces this lesson. Temperance is not denial of pleasure, but mastery over impulse. It preserves clarity and prevents the Mason from being ruled by appetite or aversion.
Fortitude: Standing Firm Under Trial
Fortitude corresponds most directly to Aristotle’s analysis of courage. Courage is not the absence of fear but the right ordering of fear. Rashness courts danger needlessly; cowardice flees duty. The mean stands firm.
The Buddha’s concept of right effort parallels this balance. Effort must be sustained without strain, persistent without aggression. In Masonic symbolism, the Plumb teaches uprightness amid pressure, while the Rough Ashlar reminds the Mason that strength is developed through labor and testing. Fortitude allows the Mason to remain steady without becoming rigid, courageous without becoming reckless.
Justice: Balance Extended to Society
Justice, for Aristotle, is the virtue that orders communal life by giving each their due. It is not merely legal compliance but fairness shaped by reason. The Buddha’s emphasis on right action and right livelihood similarly grounds ethics in compassion and non-harm.
In Freemasonry, justice is symbolized by the Level, which reminds Masons of their essential equality, and by the Perfect Ashlar, representing a life refined through discipline and fairness. Justice balances law with mercy and authority with humility. It ensures that the internal harmony cultivated by the Mason is reflected in his dealings with others.
Walking the Mean Path
Across Aristotle, the Buddha, and Freemasonry, the lesson is consistent: human nature cannot be erased, but it can be refined. Extremes promise clarity but deliver distortion. Balance requires vigilance, effort, and humility.
Freemasonry offers no shortcut to virtue. Its Working Tools are not ornaments but instruments of labor, reminding the Mason that mastery is never finished. Between rashness and cowardice lies the narrow path of courage; between indulgence and denial lies temperance; between rigidity and chaos lies justice. The Middle Way is not merely understood—it is worked.
The Mason who walks this path does not claim perfection. He commits instead to continual alignment, shaping his nature stone by stone, virtue by virtue, until the inner temple reflects balance, strength, and truth.
References
Aristotle. (1999). Nicomachean ethics (T. Irwin, Trans.). Hackett Publishing Company. (Original work published ca. 350 BCE)
Bodhi, B. (Trans.). (2000). The connected discourses of the Buddha: A translation of the Samyutta Nikaya. Wisdom Publications.
Pike, A. (1871). Morals and dogma of the ancient and accepted Scottish Rite of Freemasonry. L.H. Jenkins.
Preston, W. (1772/1812). Illustrations of masonry. Various editions.
No comments:
Post a Comment